I Pledge to the flag of the United States and to the republic for which it stands;
one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all. I have been reading a lot about whether or not "under God" should be taken out of the Pledge of Allegiance. I don't think it should be. But--yes there is a but--I think that people should be able to not include it if they wish. Also not having worry about everyone being nasty to you because of it but I know, I know baby steps.
I found this
website it has a map that shows what states require public schools and it's students to say the pledge. For example here in Minnesota, public schools are
required to do the Pledge of Allegiance. Students though are
not required themselves to participate.
Awhile back I wrote a persuasive--or argumentative if you don't agree--paper about the Pledge. I think that most people don't know the history of the Pledge of Allegiance and they should--at least Americans the rest of you probably don't give a hoot--; especially since most Americans say it repeatedly in their lives. It's okay though I'm going to tell you now.
The original version was written in 1892 and was used in public schools for Columbus Day celebrations that same year. It has been revised four times since then. The first time being in 1923 when the National Flag Council replaced "my flag" with "the Flag of the United States". "of America" was added a year later. The reason for this change was to make sure that immigrants knew which flag was being referred too.
Since the very beginning people gave the Bellamy salute while saying the Pledge. This gesture was similar to the Nazi salute. Because of the resemblance many people recently have thought that the aviation pioneer, Charles Lindbergh, was a Nazi himself because of a photo of him reciting the Pledge. To prevent controversy Franklin D. Roosevelt instituted the hand-over-heart gesture for civilians. This was officially adopted in June 22, 1942 by congress.
The Knights of Columbus were the first to use "under God" in 1952, quoting Lincoln's Gettysburg address. They tried repeatedly to change the national version to include this. It took a Presbyterian minister from Scotland to accomplish this. George MacPherson Docherty went to New York avenue Presbyterian Church near the White House to be Peter Marchall's successor.
This same church has a pew that was once rented by Abe Lincoln. After Lincoln's death it became somewhat of a monument. It also became customary for for Presidents to go to that same pew on the Sunday before Lincoln's birthday. Reverend Docherty knew this and prepared to approach President Eisenhower after his sermon. In his sermon he talked about the Pledge of Allegiance and how it could apply to any nation. According to Docherty it needed to be more then something kids just memorize. Also that the American Pledge should represent America's spirit and life as defined by Lincoln. Afterwards Docherty furthered this with a conversation with Eisenhower. Apperantley the President agreed, for her got everything going. The next daythe bill was introduced to include "under God".
Many people and groups have challenged the Pledge, and for different reasons. In the 1940's Jehovah's Witnesses, who believe that you should not swear loyalty to anyone or thing beside God, objected the requiring of students to recite the Pledge in schools. In an arguemment from Geoffrey Nunber, Geoffrey said that though it is quoting Lincoln it was in a different context. When Lincoln read the address in meant 'God willing' which gives and slightly differnt mening. Many objections have been raised saying that requiring the recitation of the Pledge violates the guarantee of the First Ammendmant.
It's only since right before writing my paper that I really thought about what the Pledge of Allegiance is. When I was in public school we said it everyday in the morning. It had no meaning to me. I disagree with Reverend Docherty about that simply adding "under God" would make it more then something to memorize. It's a blind fealty that doesn't hold it's intention or meaning. To me it's like when someone takes a stand in court and swears over the Bible. It's used in hopes that you will think about your mortality and tell the truth. But if you believe in another God/s or not one all all, what is keeping the from lying? Not fear of punishment from the Christian god.
There are several different ways I could go with this but with leave them alone....it would make a
very long post. What do you think?